The Drawbacks of Using BMI to Measure Health

Woman weighing herself on scale
Jamie Grill/Getty Images

Body mass index or BMI is a calculation that determines weight status in adults by using your weight and height. The end result tells you if you're underweight, at a healthy weight, overweight or obese. A body mass index:

  • Over 40 is considered morbidly obese.
  • Over 30 is considered obese.
  • Between 25 and 29.9 is considered overweight.
  • Between 18.5 and 24.9 is considered a healthy BMI.
  • Under 18.5 is considered underweight.

You can easily calculate your BMI by entering your measurements into an online calculator.

The Drawbacks of Using BMI

The BMI formula is so simple, it's easy to use by just about everyone. However, it's that simplicity that makes it inaccurate because it only takes into account your height and weight. Whether you're overweight or not requires much more information than just your height and weight.

Here are all the things that this BMI formula can get wrong:

  • How much muscle you have: The more you have the higher your BMI will be, even though you may be healthy
  • Frame size: A person with a big frame will have a higher BMI, although he or she may still be healthy
  • Gender: At the same BMI, women will usually have more body fat than men
  • Age: At the same BMI, an older person will usually have more fat than younger adults
  • If you're an athlete: At the same BMI, athletes will usually have less body fat than people who aren't athletes.

If you're very muscular, pregnant, or have a large frame, your BMI calculation may show you as overweight or obese, even when you're not.

How your body fat is distributed is also important for predicting your risk of heart disease, obesity-related illnesses, and death. It's a good idea to use a variety of tools to determine how healthy your weight and body fat is including waist-to-hip ratio and/or your body fat percentage.

Is BMI on Its Way Out?

What's interesting now is that new research, published in the International Journal of Obesity, suggests BMI is seriously flawed. This study revealed that millions of Americans are labeled as overweight or obese, based on their BMI, but are perfectly healthy.

The findings suggest that about 34.4 million Americans are considered overweight based on BMI and that 19.8 million are considered obese. Which is just crazy!

A Word From Verywell

As mentioned above, BMI doesn't take into account all of the factors that make us healthy. What's even more disturbing is that many companies in the U.S. use employees' BMI as a factor in determining their health care costs. So, a person with a high BMI may pay higher premiums, even though it isn't clear whether that person is genuinely overweight and unhealthy or not.

There's definitely a call to get rid of BMI as a way to measure health and weight and, because of this study, we may just see that happen. Good riddance.

Was this page helpful?

Article Sources

Verywell Fit uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial policy to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
  • Tomiyama, AJ, JM Hunger, and J. Nguyen-Cuu. "Misclassification of Cardiometabolic Health When Using Body Mass Index Categories in NHANES 2005–2012." International Journal of Obesity (2016). Doi: 10.1038/ijo.2016.17. Web. 02 Feb. 09.