The 8 Best Protein Powders of 2019

The right formulas for your goals and needs

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Our Top Picks

Best High Protein Content: Garden of Life Organic Raw at Amazon

"Reviewers love this for meal replacement, pre-workout and postworkout."

Best Taste: Orgain Organic Protein at Target

"There is a small amount of added sweetener, but it's in the form of stevia and monk fruit extract."

Best Plant-Based: Aloha Organic Protein Powder at Target

"Combination of organic pea protein, organic hemp seed protein, and organic pumpkin seed protein."

Best Whey: Naked Whey Grass Fed Whey Protein at Amazon

"Customers love how pure this formula is and think it tastes excellent in whatever they add it to."

Best for Meal Replacement: WelleCo All Natural Protein at Amazon

"Uses brown rice and pea protein and is also made with probiotics to help promote digestive health."

Best One-Ingredient Protein: NorCal Organic at Amazon

"Peanut butter lovers rejoice. This powder is so simple that it’s easy to love."

Best Protein with “Extras”: Amazing Grass Organic at Amazon

"Not only covers your protein but also has two full servings of fruits and veggies."

Best Unflavored: Realist Lifestyle REAL Whey at Amazon

"Free of artificial flavors, sweeteners, soy, gluten, and whey concentrate."

Our Top Picks

1

Best High Protein Content: Garden of Life Organic Raw Fit

4.5

Sometimes you are looking for a big protein boost, be that you are looking to gain some muscle, or for any other health and diet benefits. This raw vegan protein powder, packs a protein punch and is made with raw sprouted proteins from sources like whole grains, seeds, and legumes. The blend also contains Ashwagandha, which is an herb thought to help combat stress, inflammation, and cortisol (which, in turn, helps curb cravings). With a low-glycemic index, your blood sugar stays stable and you feel full after consuming. Reviewers love this for meal replacement, pre-workout and postworkout. The Svetol Green Coffee Bean extract helps burn fat naturally.

Flavors: Chocolate, coffee, original, and vanilla ​
Protein: 28 grams per 1-scoop serving

2

Best Taste: Orgain Organic Protein

container of orgain protein powder

 Photo from Amazon

3.5

This hits the mark on having multiple protein sources: organic brown rice protein, organic chia seed, organic hemp protein, and organic pea protein. There is a small amount of added sweetener, but it's in the form of stevia and monk fruit extract, which are no-calorie natural options. The taste and smoothness are what buyers consistently celebrate in their reviews.

Flavors: Creamy chocolate fudge and creamy vanilla bean
Protein: 21 grams per 2-scoop serving

3

Best Plant-Based: Aloha Organic Protein Powder

aloha-protein-powder
Courtesy of Target

There was a time when plant-based protein supplements were hard to come by, but now it’s harder to find one that isn’t derived from our rooted friends. So what sets Aloha apart from the rest? The combination of organic pea protein, organic hemp seed protein, and organic pumpkin seed protein found in this powder results in a “complete protein.” This means that it contains all of the essential amino acids, which is not something all plant protein powders have. Also, there are no artificial sweeteners (they use coconut sugar to sweeten) and it appeals to those who are gluten-free, soy free and dairy free.

Flavors: Chocolate and vanilla
Protein: 18 grams per 2-scoop serving

4

Best Whey: Naked Whey Grass Fed Whey Protein

This cold-processed, 100% grass fed pure whey protein, is made from cow’s milk at small farms in Northern California. The whey protein is the only ingredient so this Naked product is free of artificial flavors, colors and sweeteners. It’s also GMO-free, Soy Free and Gluten Free. If you’re looking at the Amino Acid content, this contains 5.9 of BCAAs per serving (with the full breakdown right on the label). Buyers can choose between one and five-pound bags (though certain flavors only come in one size). If Whey isn’t your choice of protein, Naked also makes other powders that have great reviews.

With over 1,600 reviews and 76% being five-star rated customers love how pure this formula is and think it tastes excellent in whatever they add it to. 

Flavors: Chocolate, strawberry, unflavored, and vanilla
Protein: 25 grams per 2-scoop serving

5

Best for Meal Replacement: WelleCo All Natural, Plant-Based Protein

What makes WelleCo the choice for meal replacement is its variety of nutrients, in particular it’s varied protein sources. Think about it like this: just as it’s recommended we eat a diet from all of the food groups, it’s also important to find a powder that incorporates more than one type of protein. This particular powder uses brown rice and pea protein and is also made with probiotics to help promote digestive health. When it comes to using protein shakes for meal replacement, make sure the fiber count is on the higher side, so you’ll feel fuller for a longer period of time (and fiber stabilizes blood sugar). In this case, there is 4g per scoop.

Flavors: Chocolate and vanilla
Protein: 16.2 grams per 1-scoop serving

6

Best One-Ingredient Protein: NorCal Organic

Peanut butter lovers rejoice. This powder is so simple that it’s easy to love. This particular NorCal Organic supplement is made entirely from peanuts, which means not only is the ingredient list short and understandable but it’s free of soy, gluten and dairy. One serving boosts 4g of fiber and 21% of your daily magnesium needs. The peanuts are 100% mechanically processed (no use of solvents) on a farm in Southwest Texas.

Each bag comes with 32 servings and is extremely affordable.

Flavor: Peanut butter​
Protein: 21 grams per 2-scoop serving

7

Best Protein with “Extras”: Amazing Grass Organic Protein Superfood

If we’re going to drink our protein, we might as well get some other valuable vitamins and nutrients in while we’re at it, right? Amazing Grass not only covers your protein but also has two full servings of fruits and veggies per serving and contains Alfalfa, Spirulina, Chlorella and Acai and has seven alkalizing greens. This “Amazon Choice” uses organic pea protein, organic quinoa, organic hemp protein and chia to round out its protein content.

While some customers note this is on the expensive side they are happy with the product and think it is worth the cost. 

Flavors: Chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, original, and vanilla Protein: 20 grams per 1-scoop serving

8

Best Unflavored: Realist Lifestyle REAL Whey Protein Isolate

Even the protein powders with the highest taste reviews still don’t appeal to some. That’s where Realist Lifestyle comes in. With just two ingredients (whey protein isolate and Non-GMO sunflower lecithin), this powder is free of artificial flavors, sweeteners, soy, gluten, and whey concentrate (nutritionists claim whey isolates are considered purer and are higher in protein than whey concentrates). This is a smart buy for anyone who is lactose intolerant too. 

Flavor: Unflavored
Protein: 20 grams per 1-scoop serving

Tested by Verywell

How We Tested

We bought two top-rated protein powders and our reviewers tested them for 78 hours. We asked our testers to consider the most important features when using these protein powders, from their taste to their ingredients. We’ve outlined the key takeaways here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.

What to Look for in Protein Powder

Taste: Some protein powders can have a somewhat chalky consistency and an unappetizing aftertaste, while others taste almost like a milkshake you look forward to drinking. Many formulas come in a wide variety of flavors, though, so if one isn’t your thing, another might be—you may just have to try a few before you find your favorite.

Purpose: While some protein powders are designed to help you lose weight, others are meant to bulk you up. Make sure you choose one that’s in line with your goals, instead of one that thwarts them. Consider not only the amount of protein in any given powder but also the type of protein it contains. Protein powders are derived from a variety of sources, including whey, pumpkin seed, hemp, and more; each has varying nutritional benefits.

Ingredients: Beyond the type of protein in a certain powder, you’ll also want to consider its additional ingredients. Some formulas are fairly simple, while others include more nutrients, sugar, or fillers. If you like to keep things clean, there are a variety of protein powders that are free of artificial ingredients and sweeteners.

Test Results: Garden of Life Organic Raw Fit (Best High Protein Content)

4.5

What We Like

  • High amount of protein per serving

  • Healthy ingredient list

  • Good value

What We Don't Like

  • Gritty texture

  • Underwhelming chocolate taste

Garden of Life Organic Raw Fit
Garden of Life
Garden of Life Raw Fit
Garden of Life Organic
Garden of Life Organic Raw Fit protein powder

This protein powder stood out because of its ingredient list, which, according to one of our testers, was “packed with organic, raw, and non-GMO items with a ton of health benefits.” The protein powder’s taste, however, wasn’t a highlight; one of our reviewers said that its chocolate flavor was “underwhelming” and that it had a “gritty-like texture when blended.” Although one tester felt that it could have included more powder given its price, she declared that “overall, the value is worth the spend for the quality ingredients and the high number of protein included per serving.”

Test Results: Orgain Organic Protein Powder (Best Taste)

container of orgain protein powder
 Photo from Amazon
3.5

What We Like

  • Filling

  • High-quality ingredients

  • Lots of protein per serving

What We Don't Like

  • Chalky texture

  • Tasted artificially sweetened

Orgain Organic Protein Powder
Orgain Protein Powder
Orgain Organic Protein
Orgain Organic
Orgain Powder

“This product is made with truly high-quality, organic ingredients,” declared one of our testers. “It's also very filling and contains a high amount of protein per serving.” In terms of negatives, one reviewer thought that its texture was “gritty and chalky” and that it “tasted like artificially sweetened chemicals.”

Was this page helpful?