The 6 Best Natural Peanut Butters of 2019

From creamy to crunchy, find the perfect spread for your tastes

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

First Look

Best Overall: Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roasted Creamy at Amazon

"Comes in light and dark roast flavors."

Best No Stir: Classic Peanut Butter by Justin's at Amazon

"Uses palm oil to give it a creamy, no-stir texture."

Best Crunchy: Jif Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter Spread at Amazon

"Longtime Jif fan? You’ll love their natural crunchy peanut butter."

Best Smooth: Good Spread Honey Peanut Butter at Amazon

"A super creamy, easily spreadable natural peanut butter."

Best With Added Vitamins: Naturally More 100% Organic at Amazon

"This creamy, organic peanut butter contains sea salt and probiotics."

Best Powdered: PBfit All-Natural Peanut Butter Powder at Amazon

"PBfit is great in smoothies or baked goods."

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roasted Creamy Peanut Butter Spread

If you’re looking for a great, well-rounded natural peanut butter, try the Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roasted Creamy Peanut Butter Spread. This all-natural peanut butter comes in light and dark roast flavors (who knew dark roast was for more than just coffee?), both of which include less than 1 percent salt. Each 16 ounce container is well worth the price for the appealing texture and robust taste Santa Cruz products are known for.

All in all, Santa Cruz is a delicious natural peanut butter that won’t leave you missing the commercial brands.

Best No Stir: Classic Peanut Butter by Justin's

One complaint we often hear about natural peanut butter is the need to stir it each time you enjoy. Solution: Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter. This natural peanut butter uses palm oil to give it a creamy, no-stir texture, without any oil separation. Justin’s also comes in a variety of flavors, like honey peanut and maple almond—and each one of them is all-natural. The jars include 16 ounces of product, and each serving has 8 grams of protein and only 2 grams of sugar.

Reviewers love Justin’s because it has a rich, peanut-y taste, and is easy to spread. Some do note that the palm oil can leave behind an aftertaste, but most say it’s not noticeable. If you want to buy some natural peanut butter that won’t make a mess every time you stir it, Justin‘s is a great choice.

Best Crunchy: Jif Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter Spread

If you’re a longtime Jif fan, you’ll love their natural crunchy peanut butter. This all-natural peanut butter is made with 90 percent peanuts, and has that crunchy texture you know and love from Jif. It’s available in either regular or honey flavors, and you can even buy in bulk up to 40 ounces. Jif crunchy peanut butter is made with peanuts, sugar, salt and palm oil—so it does have a few more ingredients than some of our other brands, giving it a slightly more conventional taste.

If you’re a recent natural peanut butter convert, Jif Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter is a great choice. It offers more natural ingredients without sacrificing the traditional peanut butter flavor you love.

Best Smooth: Good Spread Honey Peanut Butter

The Good Spread Honey Peanut Butter is a super creamy, easily spreadable natural peanut butter you’ll want to put on everything. Made with peanuts, honey and palm oil, each jar contains 16 ounces of creamy, indulgent peanut butter. It also gives back with every jar you buy: For each unit purchased, the company provides food to children suffering from malnutrition, so you can feel good about your purchase.

Best With Added Vitamins: Naturally More 100% Organic Peanut Butter

Probiotics are known to help support both digestive and immune system health, which is why we love that the Naturally More Organic Peanut Butter has added probiotics in every jar. This creamy, organic peanut butter contains peanuts, flax seeds, coconut sugar, palm oil, sea salt and probiotics. Flax seeds have a plethora of health benefits of their own, aiding digestion and protecting the heart. The Naturally More peanut butter isn’t just good for you—it also provides a rich, peanut-y taste.

Best Powdered: PBfit All-Natural Peanut Butter Powder

Though peanut butter contains healthy fats, it is high in calories and can be a deal breaker for anyone watching their diet. The PBfit All-Natural Peanut Butter Powder has almost 90 percent less fat than standard peanut butters and is a great alternative when cravings hit. Mix this powdered version with water to create a creamy, butter-like texture, and you’ll never miss those extra calories. Made with just peanuts, palm sugar and salt, PBfit is also great in smoothies or baked goods, to give you that peanut-y fix without the added fat.

If you’re skeptical, the product’s plethora of rave reviews may change your mind. Customers say the taste is so fantastic they don’t even miss standard products. If you want the taste of a peanut butter without the calories, this all-natural powder is the way to go.

Was this page helpful?